//
you're reading...

World War II

Red Sun: The Invasion of Hawai’i After Pearl Harbor. A Fictional History by Richard Ziegler and Patrick M. Patterson

Red SunRed Sun is a fictional World War II history that assumes different outcomes of several events in the Pacific Theater of World War II:

  • The carrier USS Enterprise was in Pearl Harbor during the attack, and was destroyed (and, in fact, blocked the Harbor); in fact, the carrier was due in Pearl Harbor the morning on the attacks, but was delayed due to a storm and was several hundred miles away.
  • The Japanese did indeed launch the third air strike against Pearl Harbor; in fact, they did not, fearing counter-attacks from the carriers USS Enterprise and Lexington, whose whereabouts were unknown.
  • The Japanese subsequently invaded and overtook Hawaii.

The book was written in 2001 by Richard Ziegler and Patrick M. Patterson, two instructors from the Honolulu Community College, and uses the above assumptions, combined with knowledge of Japanese and U.S. actions in other theaters to tell a compelling story. Through three different types of dialog (called Vistas, Vignettes and Voices), the story unfolds through fictional history lessons, personal accounts and reflections.

After having recently read Retribution, Max Hasting’s excellent account of the end of World War II in the Pacific, the references to other battles, to the treatments by the Japanese of their prisoners and the attitudes of the Japanese themselves all ring true in Red Sun. It is a very plausible what-if alternate history, complete with a set of notes at the end about what events were altered or assumed altered for the story.

With some great friends who grew up on the island of Oahu and still live there (which brings us the extremely wonderful privilege of visiting often), we are familiar with many of the landmarks and the terrain of Oahu. The assumptions the authors make about the invasion of the island, and the defense of those places are excellent hypothesis. The defense of the Mokapu Peninsula is spot on, mirroring that of Bataan.

The depiction of Hawai’ian independence, or independence feelings, is another well done aspect of the story. The Japanese put many puppet emperors in charge of conquered countries in their empire, and the authors mirrored this in their story. But the also integrated the strong desire for Hawai’ian independence, making it a feeling that the Japanese tried to manipulate, and that was also a source of resistance and pride for the islanders.

The end of the book (which I won’t give away) is a fictitious rendition of one of the options Max Hastings reviews in his non-fiction summary. Though I would have preferred that the novel end inside the bounds of Hawai’i, the authors do follow their alternative history premise to a logical conclusion.

An excellent tale, highly recommended for those interested in World War II and/or Hawai’i history. Thanks to Bob for another excellent recommendation.

Discussion

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Re-reading MSandT

Re-reading Tad William's Memory, Sorrow and Thorn

click on the image for more info and to support this blog

Dusk Before the Dawn

Dusk Before the Dawn

Software By the Kilo

Software by the Kilo

Archives

%d bloggers like this: